Greetings Georges. Unfortunately, I am not that well versed in various vintages of Scotch Whiskey. Like my school-teachers told me long ago, I should pay more attention to detail... However, some of my favorites are The Macallan 12 & 18 yr. , and although an enormous mass production, I must say that I am fond of Johnnie Walker Black Label (for a blend). I must say, a truly undrinkable dram has yet to make it to my glass...I try to find the good elements in everything... Be well. Enjoy the New Year! Best Wishes, Ross